03 December 2009

Introductory Post

It's that time of year again. Suddenly, your inbox is filled with letters requesting that you submit a paper to the "The 14th World Multi-Conference on Systemics, Cybernetics and Informatics: WMSCI 2010" or "WESSEX INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY" or "The International Multi-Conference on Engineering and Technological Innovation: IMETI 2009", or the "IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (that published many garbage papers last year)

Never heard of any of this because you are a philosopher getting the emails, too? Don't worry, serious computer scientists don't usually go to the conferences, although people do easily get impressed by all the names and submit a paper.

Strangely enough, all papers are accepted, as long as you have paid your registration fee. You don't actually have to come and give the paper, although the family will surely love following you to Orlando. The "Acceptance Policy" is spelled out in pseudo-scientific detail on the conference site. I paraphrase: We accept everything, because there might happen to be a good paper in there, and because a reviewer might plagiarize a paper they reject.

This conference accepted a paper back in 2005 that had been generated by a computer programmed by some MIT students, SCIgen. A nice blog discussion of that and the conference is found here. There was quite a row about this back in 2005, as one must question how scientific a conference is that accepts random (albeit well-worded) garbage and is willing to publish it. It is said that more than 1500 papers are accepted (at $ a pop that isn't chicken feed), and the "majority" are actually presented. That is not what a real conference is about, where you meet and discuss with peers working in similar areas.

How many of these thousands of papers ever get cited? That is perhaps an indication of how good the papers really are. I just searched the ACM Digital Library. There are 19 (nineteen) citations of the WMSCI conference. There have been 12 such conferences taken place.

That's not too many, so I went through the references for all 19 papers. Eleven of these papers were written by at least one of the authors of a WMSCI-published paper, so over half are self-citations. One paper is Peter G. Neumann's note of the acceptance of the fake paper in his "Risks to the Public" column in Software Engineering Notes.

As an aside, there's a fascinating paper on bibliometrics for discovering low-quality conferences published in 2007: Measuring conference quality by mining program committee characteristics.

Glancing down the lineup of invited speakers can cause quite some hilarity: Karl H. Müller, is given at CCCT2008 as being with the "University of Ljubljana (Austria)". I don't think that Austria has acutally annexed Slovenia, and a search of their web site turns up Mr. Müller as having given a talk therea few years back, but he is not listed as a teacher. He lists himself in his CV on the pages of his institute as teaching at any number of Austrian schools, but strangely, they don't list him.

Dr. Subhas C Misra is listed for this conference as being a visiting Scientist at Harvard, for another conference as being a visiting scientist at State University of New York. At another conference he is listed as the "NSERCPDF Scientist, Harvard University", but I find no mention of this program outside of his CV. Harvard includes CVs of its visiting scientists on its home page, there is no mention of Misra.

Who are these guys?

It seems that anyone can make up a fancy institute name and make themselves director, declare themselves teachers at University X (and may actually have taught there a semester or so before being put out on their ear), make up papers and fancy conferences and rush around finding themselves soooo important - but this has nothing to do with science! They can even pretend to be from some institution. Most are so large, no one can be sure that they are not actually from that place.

What can be done to stop this pseudo-science? Or do we just ignore them, but watch young people and unsuspecting colleagues pour departmental travel money into attending these conferences to present their papers? We do get a publication point out of it.....

In this blog, you will find many alerts for junk conferences i.e. conferences that you must not go. Conferences (like the IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity or the Conferences of Wessex Institute of Technology or the Nagib Callaos Conferences) that pollute our mailbox with much Spam every day.
A very good effort http://iaria-highsci.blogspot.com gave us the idea to creat our own blog.
Not to mention of course, the hundred fake conferences of IARIA, HIGHSCI, IASTED that pollute our academic world with junk or "almost" junk "conferences.
But, we will have all the academic winter 2009-2010 with many posts informing you this unacceptable situation where the first teacher was the IEEE and the IEEE Sponsored Events of IARIA, IIISCI (Nagib Callaos), WESSEX Institute of Technology and the other fruits of the academic basket!


Have a nice winter!

Similar Blogs





  1. The following IEEE Conference is also fake.
    In its first year, the organizers organizes it without IEEE.
    In the second year, they receive the "ok" from IEEE to use the IEEE name, but they misused it and they continue misusing it.
    I know that they pass every paper. Some colleagues sent them a paper for electric machines copying an article from a book of 1960 and they accepted it without comments!

    This is the fake conference:

    Ninth International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering
    co-sponsored by IEEE and IEEE-PES, IEEE Poland & Czechoslovakia Section
    Prague, Czech Republic, May 16-19, 2010

    Call for Papers
    The aim of the Conference is to promote a Forum, where people involved with electrical power systems may exchange their experiences and present solutions found for actual and future problems. Prospective authors are invited to submit papers within the scope of the Conference.


    31 January 2010 - Full Manuscript submission (IEEE Xplore compatible) to our Submission System

    28 February 2010 - Notification of acceptance

    31 March 2010 - Final Paper Submission

    31 March 2010 - Registration and payment

    16-19 May 2010 - Conference

    IEEE Conference Publication

    Accepted papers will be published in IEEE Xplore
    IEEE Catalog Number: CFP1051I-ART
    Library of Congress: 2009909493

    Selected papers will be recommended for publication in: Electrical Review (Przeglad Elektrotechniczny) ISSN 0033-2097

  2. Here is another conference that deserves an entry here. The magnitude of corruption isn't too high, but corruption is still corruption. And it's happening under the IEEE banner.
    I'll see if I can find the proceedings and put them up too.